Updated
A low commercial construction appraisal can cut the senior loan and leave you with more cash to raise before closing. On a $12M project, a reduction from $8.4M to $7.2M leaves a $1.2M funding gap if the budget and other sources stay the same.
Construction appraisal gap calculator
Resize the loan after appraisal and see how much additional cash or approved funding the project needs.
Estimated results
- Original modeled senior loan
- $8,400,000
- Revised modeled senior loan
- $7,200,000
- Gap before new funding
- $1,200,000
- Cash still needed after new funding
- $1,200,000
How the estimate adds up
- Both cases use the same entered project costs and lender limits. Confirm the revised senior commitment and retest the payoff or investor redemption at refinance when you add new capital.
Borrowers
Submit a construction appraisal gap dealBrokers with a client deal
Sign up as a brokerCalculate the gap · Compare ways to fill it · Prepare a lender request
Why did the appraisal change the loan amount?
Ask the lender how much you can borrow now. Loan-to-cost (LTC) compares the loan with the costs the lender accepts. Loan-to-value (LTV) compares the loan with the value the lender uses. If both caps apply, the lower dollar amount sets the ceiling. The lender may offer less if cash flow or sponsor funds fall short. Ask which factor drove the cut.
Ask which figure the lender used. The report can give several estimates of value. One may reflect the land as it is today. A second can reflect what the property is worth when the work is done. A third may reflect what it is worth once leasing and income are stable. An apartment building can be ready to open months before rents reach that level. Bank appraisal guidelines
| Number to confirm | What to ask |
|---|---|
| Cost limit | Which land, hard and soft costs are eligible? Did the lender remove any costs from its calculation? |
| Value limit | Which appraised figure and effective date apply? Did the lender use as-is, as-completed or as-stabilized value? |
| Revised loan commitment | Which limit controls now? Are any proceeds reserved for fees, interest or specific costs? |
| Cash available at closing | How much will fund now, what equity has to go in first and what is held for later draws? |
Get the revised sources and uses. This is the list of what you owe and who will pay it. If the lender dropped a cost from its sizing, keep that bill in your budget. Put the new source of cash next to it. Check how much of the new loan funds at closing. The gap for the whole job can be larger or smaller than the amount you need that day.
Worked example with a $12M construction budget
An apartment developer has a $12M project budget, all eligible in this example. It includes the lender’s assumed land allowance and budgeted carry. The developer planned for a $14M as-completed value. The appraisal supports $12M. Assume the lender keeps its modeled caps of 70% of eligible cost and 60% of as-completed value.
| Sizing decision | Dollars available |
|---|---|
| Cost limit in both cases | 70% of $12M = $8.4M |
| Value limit before appraisal, using the sponsor’s estimate | 60% of $14M = $8.4M |
| Value limit after the appraisal | 60% of $12M = $7.2M |
| Revised senior loan | $7.2M, equal to 60% of the $12M cost |
| Total equity or other approved funding needed | $12M − $7.2M = $4.8M |
The sponsor already has $3.6M in the original capital plan. Assume the lender accepts $1.2M of land owned free and clear, and the sponsor can commit $2.4M in cash. The revised loan and those sources add up to $10.8M. The remaining $1.2M has to come from a new source, an approved reduction in uses or a combination of the two.
The appraisal is $2M below the sponsor’s estimate and the loan is $1.2M smaller. Those numbers are connected by the 60% value cap. Ask the lender to confirm the loan sizing before asking a partner for a specific amount. If you need to revisit which land contributions the lender will accept, start with the construction budget and equity calculator.
What if you can reduce the construction budget by $400K?
Assume the lender and contractor approve a change that brings eligible costs to $11.6M. If the appraised value stays at $12M, the 60% value limit still gives a $7.2M loan. With $3.6M already committed, the gap drops to $800K. If the revised plans instead support only $11M of as-completed value, the same value cap reduces the loan to $6.6M. Now $11.6M of costs less $6.6M of loan proceeds and $3.6M of existing funds leaves a $1.4M gap.
Get sign-off before relying on a cut. A bid adjustment for the same scope can have a different effect from removing rentable space or postponing a required utility. If the project is phased, verify that each finished part can open when expected. Give the lender the revised plans, bid and schedule, then ask it to run both loan limits again.
Can you get the appraisal or loan sizing reviewed?
Start by checking what the appraiser valued. Is the unit count right? Did the report use the latest plans in the file? Check the rent and lease terms it used. A permit issued after the appraisal date can be new information. A permit that was already in the file may help correct an error. Put the date and source next to each fact. Send the evidence through the lender’s review process. Ask what the lender needs and how long the review could take. Appraisal review guidance for banks
If the report accurately describes the project, ask what would change the credit decision. A second lender may use a different eligible cost basis or advance policy. Get its process for ordering or reviewing an appraisal and an estimate of the time needed. Compare its likely terms against the actual contractor deposit, land purchase deadline or financing contingency. A later close can change the budget through extra carry, a bid expiration or an extension fee.
Keep a workable capital plan with the current appraisal while any review is pending. If you have already broken ground and the appraisal triggered a draw freeze, document the payoff, remaining work and cash due to trades. That calls for a mid-construction refinance review.
Which money has to arrive before the first draw?
Flag each bill due before loan funds can be released. Common items include the land payment, third-party fees and an early order from a trade. Get the updated initial advance, the order in which equity and loan funds go in, and the first date an investor can fund. A source can cover eligible work after closing while leaving a deposit unfunded on the day it is due.
Write down the date you need a decision from each provider, starting with the first payment deadline and working backward. Ask the senior lender which items can be advanced against delivery and which require completion or inspection. If the construction budget balances but the first month runs short, ask about changing the payment schedule or bringing part of a committed contribution forward.
How can you fill a construction loan gap?
Ask how much cash each option adds and when it can be spent. Find out what each party must approve. Put the dates on the same schedule the senior lender uses for equity and draws. If a source is still under review, mark it as pending and show what bills would be due while you wait.
| Funding option | What to confirm before relying on it |
|---|---|
| More sponsor or partner cash | Available cash by date, ownership terms and liquidity left for contingencies |
| Preferred equity | Distribution priority, accrued return, redemption terms, investor approval rights and senior consent |
| Mezzanine debt | Net proceeds, interest, maturity, collateral, remedies and the agreement with the senior lender |
| Commercial Property Assessed Clean Energy (C-PACE) | Eligible scope, local approval, mortgage lender consent, advance dates and the effect of the assessment on the exit |
Sponsor cash and preferred equity
Start with cash you and your partners can put into the job. How much is free after other commitments? When can the money reach the borrower? Set aside enough to cover a cost increase or early bills while rents come in. If you bring in a new partner, show the lender who will own what and how much cash each partner will put in.
A preferred equity investor contributes equity with agreed priority over common equity in certain distributions. Ask when its return is paid or accrues, when it can demand a buyout under the agreement, and whether it can take control if the project misses a deadline. Map those rights against the senior loan’s restrictions on control changes and distributions. Then compare the sponsor’s proceeds and remaining obligations at a later sale or refinance. Common joint venture equity vs. preferred equity
Mezzanine debt
A real estate mezzanine loan often uses a pledge of ownership interests in a property-owning entity as collateral. The senior construction lender may restrict the debt or the exercise of remedies under that pledge. Ask if the senior lender will allow it, what agreements between lenders are required and whether there are restrictions on paying interest or principal. Check the mezzanine lender’s right to cure a senior default and what happens if construction takes longer than the mezzanine loan term. Mezzanine lending structures in a public SEC filing
Compare the total committed amount with the net dollars available to pay approved project bills. If mezzanine fees come out of the advance, the remaining cash has to cover the construction uses. If interest requires monthly payments before the building earns rent, show which reserve or sponsor funds pay it. Ask whether additional guaranties are required. The terms can change the cash you need even when two offers show the same initial amount.
C-PACE for eligible costs
C-PACE finances eligible work and is repaid through an assessment on the property. Where a local program permits new construction, ask whether planned equipment, envelope work or another specific cost qualifies. Get a written scope determination and the required mortgage lender consent. Show the recurring assessment and how it will be handled at refinance or sale. U.S. Department of Energy C-PACE overview · DOE toolkit for new construction
In the $1.2M gap example, suppose a program approves $800K for eligible costs already in the budget. If $40K of new financing charges comes out of those proceeds, $760K can go toward eligible project costs. The gap falls to $440K, assuming the senior loan, the budget for the original work and the other sources stay the same. Ask when the $760K can actually pay bills and whether the senior lender will change its loan amount or its draw schedule. Test the assessment with the proposed refinance lender early. C-PACE financing guide
Can the permanent loan repay the revised funding?
Put every payoff, investor redemption and closing charge on one schedule. Compare it with what the new loan can advance after its own underwriting. If you expect an assessment or another obligation to stay in place, ask the exit lender how it affects operating income, debt service and permitted collateral. Confirm the actual amounts and timing with each provider.
Assume the developer in the $1.2M gap example uses preferred equity for the full amount. Use a hypothetical 12% annual simple accrual for 24 months and assume the agreement requires redemption at refinance, with zero interim distributions. Both the senior balance and the preferred equity have to come out of the proceeds in this case.
| Refinance calculation | Amount |
|---|---|
| Senior construction payoff assumed at refinance | $7.2M |
| Preferred equity redemption | $1.2M invested + $288K accrued = $1.488M |
| Estimated closing costs for the refinance | $120K |
| Total proceeds needed | $8.808M |
| Projected gross refinance and resulting gap | $8.3M of proceeds leaves $508K still due |
These are example terms. The projected refinance is a separate assumption about the property after lease-up. The preferred equity solves the construction funding gap and creates another funding need if the exit proceeds come in at $8.3M. If the parties would allow a later redemption, confirm when, what return could accrue and whether the next lender would permit it. Price a longer hold and a smaller permanent loan before you sign. Use the construction exit calculator to check the property income and loan sizing in your own numbers.
What should you send for a second financing review?
Give the reviewer the original loan amount, the revised amount and the deadline that puts the project at risk. State whether you need a new senior construction loan or approval for a specific capital source alongside the lender you already have.
- Appraisal and lender feedback. Include the date, the value opinions you received, the value used in the loan decision and the written reason for the reduction.
- Revised budget and drawings. Identify which costs are eligible under the current lender’s terms, which are already paid and whether any scope change depends on an approval.
- Sources of funds and dates. List committed land and cash equity, the funding still needed and when an investor or financing source can actually wire it.
- Lender and contractor terms. Share the current term sheet, closing target, any deposit dates and the advance schedule. Flag any approvals still required for additional capital.
- Exit math. Show projected refinance or sale proceeds, payoffs, investor redemption and any assessments or reserves required afterward.
If you have revised terms and a budget, request a commercial construction review. Put the closing date and the amount still needed near the top. If you are comparing a change of lenders, bring both the sizing and timing questions to that conversation. Commercial construction lender guide