Updated
If the sale or refinance comes up short on a non-recourse commercial construction loan, the lender generally looks to the property and any other pledged collateral. The sponsor can still sign guarantees to finish the job, cover bills while the building leases up or pay losses tied to specific events.
Completion and carry exposure calculator
Model the cash needed under separate completion and carry obligations using the bills and funds each one covers.
Estimated results
- Estimated completion cash need
- $450,000
- Estimated carry cash need
- $150,000
- Combined if the bills are separate
- $600,000
How the estimate adds up
- Include each bill and each dollar of available funding once. Use the signed agreements to check the covered expenses, funding dates, repayment liability and carve-outs.
Borrowers
Submit a non-recourse construction dealBrokers with a client deal
Sign up as a brokerRead the guaranty terms · Work through a $9M loan · Prepare your loan request
What does non-recourse mean on a construction term sheet?
Start with the clause that limits who can be made to pay the debt. Read it with the loan agreement and each guaranty. The borrower still owes the loan. The property still secures it. Check who signs each form and what that person agrees to do. A sponsor may agree to finish the work while the loan limits their liability for the debt.
| Obligation to check | What it may require from a signer |
|---|---|
| Payment or repayment guaranty | Payment of all or a defined portion of the loan or covered amounts after a stated trigger |
| Completion guaranty | Deliver the promised work or fund specified costs of getting the project to completion |
| Cost-overrun guaranty | Fund costs above the agreed budget or available funds, as defined in the documents |
| Carry guaranty | Cover named expenses, such as interest, taxes, insurance or operating deficits, for an agreed period or until a milestone |
| Non-recourse carve-out guaranty | Pay a covered loss or assume broader liability after a defined exception is triggered |
Ask for each form you would sign. One guaranty may cover more than one risk. Check what it means to finish the job. Is the building ready when people can move in? Does the work include a tenant’s fit-out after the shell is done? Read the construction contract for what the builder must do. Read the guaranty for what the signer owes the lender.
Mark when each bill could come due. A completion guaranty may cover the lights and sprinklers you need to open the building. A carry guaranty may cover taxes and insurance while units fill. Ask who pays interest during each period. If two forms cover the same bill, find out how a payment under one is credited under the other. Put the dates and amounts on your cash plan.
Which lenders should you ask?
Start with lenders who fund your type of build, in your market, at the size you need. Ask who must sign for the debt and who must agree to finish the job. Some lenders will consider a cap on the payment guaranty. Ask when it can drop and by how much. Other terms may call for more cash up front or more cash on hand for overruns. Get the proposed loan size and equity amount with the draft guaranty so you can price the whole deal. Commercial construction lender comparison
Worked example with a $9M construction loan
Assume a developer signs a $9M construction loan to build apartments. The loan limits who can be made to pay the debt if a sale or refinance falls short. The sponsor signs for completion and carry. A delay pushes back the work and move-ins by four months. The builder updates the cost to finish. The sponsor adds up the bills due before rents come in.
| What changed | Modeled cash exposure |
|---|---|
| Remaining construction work the completion guaranty covers | $2M |
| Undrawn loan proceeds available for the same work | $1.55M |
| Estimated completion shortfall | $2M − $1.55M = $450K |
| Extra carry for four months | 4 × $60K = $240K |
| Reserve available for those covered carry costs | $90K |
| Estimated carry shortfall | $240K − $90K = $150K |
That gives the signer $600K of combined exposure if both amounts are due and cover separate bills. The loan must still be able to fund its share. The $90K is set aside for carry. The $1.55M is available for work. Give the lender a list of bills and due dates so it can confirm which funds can pay each one.
Now suppose the lender holds back $200K of the $1.55M until that work is paid for. Only $1.35M is free on the due date. The cash shortfall rises to $650K when those bills are due. Ask when the lender will release the held funds and if the signer can get credit for what they paid. The definition of which loan funds are available matters when you work out how much a signer owes. Example completion guaranty filed with the SEC
What if the completed building cannot refinance the full balance?
Assume the building later has $8.75M outstanding and can refinance for $8.35M net, leaving a $400K payoff gap. The lender can enforce the maturity date and its collateral remedies. If the signed agreements limit repayment recourse and no relevant exception has been triggered, the lender’s remedy for the market-driven shortfall in this example is limited to the collateral. Review the project’s completion, carry and carve-out obligations on their own terms.
Now assume a different offer includes a payment guaranty capped at 20% of outstanding principal. At an $8.75M balance, that formula gives a $1.75M cap. Ask which amounts can be collected under that cap, what event makes them due and whether interest or costs sit inside it. The actual deficiency and the stated cap tell you different things. If you expect the building to finish before permanent funding is available, test the maturity, extension and takeout dates against actual occupancy. Apartment lease-up refinance guide
When do carve-outs create loss liability or full recourse?
A carve-out is an exception to the limits on who pays. Start with the event that sets it off. Whose act counts? What may the lender collect? Check whether there is time to fix a breach and who can give written consent. Follow references to other loan documents for terms the clause uses.
A loss-based provision can make a signer pay for harm caused by a listed event. If it covers misuse of rents, ask how the lender measures the loss and whether the signer also pays the cost to enforce its rights. A full-recourse provision can make the signer liable for the whole unpaid loan and other amounts the agreement covers. This is also called springing recourse. Check how the documents treat bankruptcy and transfers made without required consent. Fannie Mae publishes examples of a non-recourse agreement and a separate guaranty for permanent multifamily loans. Fannie Mae multifamily loan documents
Ask counsel to identify who can set off each clause. For example, one person may manage the project company while an outside partner signs a guaranty. The investor should understand whether another party’s actions can trigger liability and which approvals the operating agreement requires. Ask how transfers of an ownership interest, changes in control and new pledges are treated. If a partner wants to join after closing, have the lender confirm the required consent before finalizing the change.
What releases a completion or carry guaranty?
Ask the lender to name the evidence and approvals needed for each release. A certificate of occupancy can show that a building may be occupied. The guaranty may require other items, such as lien waivers, proof that trades were paid, final sign-offs or a completed set of funded improvements. A loan for more than one building may apply different release conditions by phase. Confirm whether one building can qualify while common utilities or parking work remains underway.
Carry may end at a different point. It can run to a date or to a specified operating milestone. Ask what income or occupancy measure the lender uses, which months it tests and whether the building has to satisfy that measure over time. Check whose cash pays if the reserve is exhausted while a lease-up or refinance is delayed. You can estimate the interest impact of a slower draw schedule with the construction draw and interest calculator.
Ask which obligations survive a completion release, a maturity extension, a transfer or repayment. For example, a lender may confirm completion and keep an obligation for earlier losses or a separate indemnity in place according to the documents. List the release conditions in the project calendar and assign someone to collect the evidence. Request written lender confirmation when the conditions are satisfied. Ask how extensions affect obligations before accepting new dates.
How would a guaranty step down in dollars?
Use the same $8.75M balance. Assume the written offer says the payment cap steps down from 20% to 10% of outstanding principal once the lender accepts the completed work and receives final lien waivers. At that balance, the cap changes from $1.75M to $875K once the stated conditions are met. Ask when the lender measures that balance and how already accrued claims are handled. Find out what happens if only part of the work is accepted.
For example, suppose the contractor expects occupancy in June and final waivers in August. Use the later documented milestone when calculating how long the higher cap remains in place. Ask whether the carry guaranty follows a separate lease-up test. Showing those dates beside the budget helps each signer plan resources and decide which conditions to discuss with the lender.
How should you compare two non-recourse offers?
Give both lenders the same budget, draw schedule and exit assumptions. Ask for the terms you would see at closing. A headline saying “non-recourse” tells you to look for the repayment limitation. The loan agreement, funding rules and each guaranty determine who can owe what.
- Name the payor. List which person or entity will sign each obligation. If there are multiple guarantors, find out whether each signs for an agreed share or whether the lender can collect the covered amount from any signer.
- Price each trigger. Use a cost overrun, a delayed opening and a smaller refinance to see which obligations can come due. Ask whether more than one obligation can apply to the same bill and how credits work.
- Check the money still available. Ask which undrawn funds, reserves and borrower contributions give the signer a credit. Get the conditions that must be met before those amounts are available.
- Know when a lender can make a demand. Confirm what starts the clock, what notices and cure rights apply and whether the lender must exercise other remedies first.
- Put a date or test on reductions. Record the measured balance, evidence, approvals and continuing obligations for each cap reduction or release.
Have counsel compare the loan agreement, guaranties and any indemnities against the proposed terms. If the sponsor is new to development, show who controls the construction budget and who would have the resources to perform. First apartment build with an experienced contractor
What if two partners share the risk?
Put the lender’s proposed signatures next to the partners’ agreement about funding. A partner might be responsible for a share of the equity calls between owners and still sign a guaranty that makes it responsible to the lender for the full covered bill. Ask counsel to identify how those terms interact and how one partner would be reimbursed if it pays for another. Discuss what happens if a partner cannot fund its share or wants to be released before the project is complete.
Give the lender a picture of available cash for each signer after their other commitments. A partner can own substantial real estate and have little cash available in the week a subcontractor must be paid. Estimate when the signer could move money, how much is already committed to the project’s equity and what resources would cover a guaranty call. Use the same assumptions when comparing offers.
What should you send for a non-recourse construction loan review?
Lead with the asset, location, project cost, loan request and approval status. State which form of repayment recourse you want to limit and what support the team is prepared to discuss. Include the details that let a lender evaluate whether the project can finish and repay the loan with that structure.
- Project and construction package. Send permits and plans available to date, the contractor’s scope and bid, the draw schedule and contingency.
- Support and signing authority. Identify the sponsor, project lead and proposed guarantors. Show who would fund covered construction or operating costs and what liquidity is available to each potential signer.
- Proposed guarantees. Send any existing term sheet or drafts. Mark the repayment cap or limitation, completion and carry obligations, carve-outs and requested release conditions.
- Expected repayment. Include the projected takeout date and a backup if lease-up or permanent financing takes longer. Show who can cover the added bills during that period.
If you have a budget and a defined request, request commercial construction financing. Include the guaranty question you want addressed before ordering reports. If you are financing roads, utilities or finished lots before vertical construction, use the non-recourse land development guide. For a loan on a completed property, see how commercial bridge loan guarantees work.