Blog
Marion County Property Tax Guide 2026 for Investors
By Jason Taken · Principal
Marion County property tax investor guide 2026 — assessments, appeals, DSCR opex budgeting, and BRRRR reassessment risk for Indianapolis rental sponsors.
Marion County property tax is the most under-modeled opex line in Indianapolis DSCR underwriting. Sponsors who carry the seller’s tax bill through refi get ratio surprises when the property loses its homestead status and the rehab raises assessed value.
This 2026 Marion County property tax investor guide covers how bills are built, the 2% rental cap, BRRRR reassessment risk, appeals, and honest opex budgeting for DSCR loans Indiana and Indianapolis DSCR hold math.
Marion County tax structure — how bills are built
Indiana’s Department of Local Government Finance (DLGF) lays out the bill in its Tax Bill 101 guide. The steps run in this order:
| Step | What happens |
|---|---|
| 1. Gross assessed value | The assessor’s value for land and improvements |
| 2. Deductions | Subtracted to reach net assessed value (homestead deductions do not apply to rentals) |
| 3. Tax rate | Net assessed value × the district’s rate per $100 |
| 4. Credits | Local and state credits, if any |
| 5. Circuit-breaker cap | Tax limited to 1% of gross AV for homesteads, 2% for other residential, 3% for other property |
| 6. Referendum levies | Voter-approved school or building levies are exempt from the cap and added on top |
The cap does not lower the local tax rate. It limits what one property pays.
Assessed value ≠ appraised value — but after a rehab and a sale, expect the assessor’s number to move toward the market.
State hold context: Indiana DSCR investor guide 2026
Certified 2026 tax rates — selected Marion County districts
Rates below are the certified gross tax rates per $100 of assessed value for 2026, from the DLGF’s 2026 certified tax rates by district, listed on its reports page.
| Taxing district | 2026 gross rate per $100 AV | Equivalent % |
|---|---|---|
| Indianapolis Center | $2.7291 | 2.73% |
| Indianapolis Washington | $2.6932 | 2.69% |
| Indianapolis Lawrence | $2.6927 | 2.69% |
| Indianapolis Perry | $2.6923 | 2.69% |
| Indianapolis Warren | $2.6908 | 2.69% |
| Indianapolis Pike | $2.6830 | 2.68% |
| Town of Speedway | $3.1302 | 3.13% |
| Beech Grove Center | $4.2369 | 4.24% |
Across every Marion County district in the file, rates run from about $2.36 to $4.24 per $100. That matters because all of them are above 2%.
Why rentals land on the 2% cap
Run the math on a rental in the Indianapolis Center district. A $238,000 gross AV × 2.7291% equals about $6,495 before the cap. The 2% cap for other residential property limits it to $4,760 a year, or about $397/mo. Add any voter-approved referendum levy shown on the bill.
The practical rule for Marion County rentals: budget 2% of gross assessed value, plus referendum charges. A rate of 0.9%–1.1% is homestead math, not rental math.
The homestead trap is where BRRRR models break. If the seller lived in the house, their bill reflected the homestead deduction and the 1% cap. Once you own it as a rental, it moves to the 2% cap, even before the rehab raises the value.
Worked example — BRRRR reassessment shock
Illustration — Bates-Hendricks SFR BRRRR, using the 2% rental cap:
| Stage | Gross AV | Annual tax | Monthly tax |
|---|---|---|---|
| Seller’s bill (homestead, 1% cap) | $145,000 | up to $1,450 | up to $121 |
| Purchase as rental (2% cap) | $145,000 | $2,900 | $242 |
| Post-rehab rental | $220,000 | $4,400 | $367 |
| AV matches refi appraisal | $238,000 | $4,760 | $397 |
Now put each tax number into the same DSCR test. Assumptions: $1,750/mo rent, a $178,500 loan (75% of $238,000) at 7.25% on a 30-year schedule, and $110/mo landlord insurance.
| Tax assumption | PITIA | DSCR |
|---|---|---|
| Seller’s homestead bill ($121) | ~$1,449 | ~1.21 |
| Purchase-year rental bill ($242) | ~$1,570 | ~1.11 |
| Post-rehab rental bill ($397) | ~$1,725 | ~1.01 |
The deal that looked like a comfortable 1.21 is barely above 1.0 once the real rental bill arrives. Thin deals fail on exactly this line.
Marion County submarkets — illustrative tax bands
Post-rehab AV ranges below are illustrative for typical investor stock. Monthly tax applies the 2% rental cap, before referendum levies.
| Submarket | Illustrative post-rehab AV | Monthly tax at 2% cap | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bates-Hendricks | $220K–$245K | $367–$408 | Reassessment common post-BRRRR |
| Fountain Square | $250K–$285K | $417–$475 | Higher AV = higher tax |
| Garfield Park | $200K–$230K | $333–$383 | Lower AV band |
| Lawrence | $185K–$215K | $308–$358 | Ranch stock |
| Irvington | $230K–$260K | $383–$433 | Historic district |
Always pull the current tax bill and assessor record at acquisition — not a Zillow estimate. Check the property-class line to see whether the seller’s bill carried a homestead.
Duplex tax — Marion County
A duplex is assessed as one parcel with a single tax bill:
| Line | Amount |
|---|---|
| Post-rehab AV (duplex) | $248,000 |
| Cap rate for rental residential | 2% of gross AV |
| Annual tax before referendum levies | ~$4,960 |
| Monthly (DSCR opex) | ~$413 |
Duplex gross rent of $2,550/mo absorbs tax better than an SFR. In an illustration with a 75% LTV loan at 7.25% and $150/mo insurance, PITIA is about $1,832 and DSCR about 1.39. That spread is part of the duplex advantage in Indianapolis DSCR hold math.
Proof: Fountain Square case study — Marion County duplex BRRRR.
Tax appeals — when investors push back
| Ground | Success profile |
|---|---|
| Over-assessment vs comps | Strong if recent comps are lower |
| Incorrect sq ft / bed count | Strong if the assessor record is wrong |
| Wrong cap applied | Check the cap line on your bill |
| Homestead removed | N/A — investment property |
Process, per the DLGF’s appeals overview:
- File Form 130 with the local assessing official, stating why the value is wrong
- Attend an informal conference; the assessor recommends approval or denial
- If denied, the county PTABOA reviews it
- Further appeal goes to the Indiana Board of Tax Review, then the Indiana Tax Court
Subjective appeals cover only the current year’s value. Objective errors — a wrong description, a math mistake, or the wrong cap — can reach back up to three years on Form 130, with a Form 17T claim for any refund.
Watch the deadline on your notice. The DLGF’s Form 11 notice table listed June 15, 2026 appeal deadlines for many counties. Marion County’s row showed no posted date when checked, and a county may use the tax bill itself as the notice. Calendar the deadline the day the notice arrives.
Budget $500–$1,500 for appeal help on high-AV doors — worth it when AV looks overstated by $30K+, which is about $600/yr of tax at the 2% cap.
Reassessment and payment calendar
| Event | Date or rule | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Spring installment (2026) | May 11, 2026 | DLGF due dates |
| Fall installment (2026) | November 10, 2026 | DLGF due dates |
| New cyclical reassessment | Began July 1, 2026, for 2026 pay 2027 taxes | DLGF cyclical reassessment |
| Inspection pace | About 25% of parcels a year over four years | Same |
Assessed values can change with new construction, additions, remodeling, or changes in land use, per the DLGF. A permitted rehab is exactly the kind of change that puts your parcel on the assessor’s radar. Under the four-year cycle, an assessor also physically inspects about a quarter of parcels each year.
Late payment adds penalties, so escrow or calendar both installments. When a DSCR loan escrows taxes, that makes an accurate tax line part of your payment, not just your pro forma.
DSCR pro forma — honest tax budgeting
| Rule | Application |
|---|---|
| Model post-rehab AV | Use appraisal × 0.95–1.0 |
| Cap math | 2% of gross AV for rentals |
| Referendum levies | Add from the current bill; they sit outside the cap |
| No homestead deduction | Never carry the seller’s homestead bill forward |
| Refi timing | The bill may lag the new AV by a cycle — underwrite the higher number anyway |
Permanent debt: DSCR loans Indiana at 5.75%–10.5% — tax opex is non-negotiable in the ratio.
Marion vs Allen vs Lake County — investor comparison
Certified 2026 gross rates, from the same DLGF file, for one representative district in each county:
| County (district) | 2026 gross rate per $100 | Illustrative post-rehab SFR AV | Monthly tax at 2% cap |
|---|---|---|---|
| Marion (Indianapolis Center) | $2.7291 | $235K | ~$392 |
| Allen (Fort Wayne – Wayne) | $2.8975 | $198K | ~$330 |
| Lake (Hammond) | $3.7529 | $215K | ~$358 |
All three rates exceed 2%, so the rental cap governs in each. The tax difference between these markets comes mostly from assessed value and referendum levies, not the headline rate.
Compare: Indianapolis vs Fort Wayne cash flow 2026 · NW Indiana DSCR vs Chicago spillover · hard money lenders Fort Wayne · hard money lenders Evansville
BRRRR acquisition — tax due diligence checklist
| Item | Source |
|---|---|
| Current tax bill and cap line | County treasurer |
| Homestead status on seller’s bill | Tax bill / auditor record |
| Assessed value | Assessor portal |
| Referendum levies | Tax bill, cap adjustment line |
| Tax arrears | Title commitment |
| Special assessments | Tax bill, other charges table |
| Abatement expiration | Economic development (rare on SFR) |
| Post-rehab AV estimate | Appraiser or assessor comp |
Bridge acquisition: hard money lenders Indianapolis at 8.99%–13.5% IO
Marion vs Chicago — compare bills, not reputations
Indiana’s reputation for low property taxes comes largely from the 1% homestead cap. Investors do not get that cap. Before treating Indianapolis as a tax discount to Chicago, pull the actual bill on the Marion County rental and on the Chicago comparable. Then run both through the same DSCR test. Landlord law matters to the hold too: Indiana landlord-tenant law investors 2026
Red flags — Marion County tax
- Seller’s homestead bill used in the pro forma — the most common DSCR killer
- Tax sale property — arrears cure before close
- Special assessment for sidewalk/alley — confirm balance
- Under-assessed duplex — reassessment cliff at refi
- Referendum levy missing from your model
- TIF district — verify rate stability
Portfolio tax strategy — four Marion doors
Illustration, using the 2% rental cap and hypothetical rents:
| Door | AV | Monthly tax at 2% cap | Rent | Tax as % of rent |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bates-Hendricks SFR | $238K | $397 | $1,750 | 22.7% |
| Garfield Park duplex | $248K | $413 | $2,550 | 16.2% |
| Fountain Square SFR | $262K | $437 | $1,950 | 22.4% |
| Lawrence SFR | $208K | $347 | $1,650 | 21.0% |
Aggregate monthly tax opex: about $1,593 on $7,900 of gross rent — roughly 20% of gross. That is the honest number for Marion County rentals at these values. The duplex carries the lowest tax share, which is why small multifamily often underwrites best here.
No-seasoning refi context: Indiana BRRRR no-seasoning cash-out 2026
Bottom line
Marion County’s 2026 gross tax rates exceed 2% in every district. Rentals therefore pay about 2% of gross assessed value, plus referendum levies. On typical post-rehab Indianapolis stock that is $330–$475/mo. BRRRR operators must model the rental bill at post-rehab value, never the seller’s homestead bill. Honest tax lines keep DSCR loans Indiana refis from failing at the appraisal stage.
Ratio and leverage sanity checks (2026)
Before you increase rehab scope on a Marion County BRRRR:
| Check | Target |
|---|---|
| Bridge IO carry | Model 8.99%–13.5% on approved LTC |
| DSCR exit | 5.75%–10.5% at 1.0+ on in-place rent |
| Tax line | 2% of post-rehab AV plus referendum levies |
| Reserves | 2–4 months interest on heavy rehab |
| Exit doc | Written refi or sale path before draw #1 |
Submit scenario · DSCR calculator.
Sources
- Indiana DLGF — Tax Bill 101 (caps, credits, referendum exemption)
- Indiana DLGF — 2026 certified tax rates by district
- Indiana DLGF — appeals process
- Indiana DLGF — Form 11 notices and appeal deadlines
- Indiana DLGF — statewide cyclical reassessment
- Indiana DLGF — property tax due dates
Marion County Property Tax Guide 2026: Assessments and Appeals — next step (2026)
Send Jaken Finance Group the address, the current tax bill, and your post-rehab value estimate, and we will size the DSCR exit on the real rental tax line.
Submit scenario · Pre-qualify · (833) 264-7776.