Skip to main content

Fountain Square Indianapolis Funded BRRRR Case Study

Funded deal: Fountain Square duplex BRRRR — $118K buy, $48K rehab, 85% LTC hard money, Indiana DSCR refi 70% LTV. Marion County walkthrough.

Deal snapshot

Location Fountain Square, Indianapolis, IN
Property type Side-by-side duplex (2/1 per unit)
Loan type Hard money BRRRR → Indiana DSCR refi
Loan amount $166,000 bridge (85% LTC) → $150,500 DSCR refi
Close time 10 business days acquisition

Investor challenge

The sponsor needed to close an estate-sale duplex in Fountain Square before a faster cash buyer dropped price. Conventional financing could not meet the 10-day decision window, and one side still had a below-market tenant — rehab had to proceed with partial occupancy without blowing the draw schedule.

Jaken Finance Group’s solution

Jaken Finance Group structured 85% LTC hard money at 10.5% interest-only with four milestone draws tied to electrical, HVAC, kitchen/bath, and finish scopes. Proof of funds on Day 2 secured the contract; file closed on Day 10 with LLC vesting and line-item scope aligned to Marion County duplex comps.

Outcome

After $48,000 rehab and stabilization at $2,750/mo gross, the property appraised at $215,000. Indiana DSCR refi at 70% LTV returned ~$32,000 for the sponsor’s next Near Eastside acquisition.

Indiana DSCR hub: DSCR loans Indiana · hard money lenders Indianapolis · Fountain Square neighborhood

Acquisition

Property: Duplex — one side vacant, dated mechanicals, active tenant other side at below-market rent
Purchase: $118,000 · LLC vesting
Close: Day 10 · 85% LTC hard money at 10.5% IO

Seller situation: Estate — four offers, two conventional (30+ day), one cash lowball. Proof of funds Day 2 won.

Hard money and rehab

DrawScopeRelease
1Panel, rough electrical, demo vacant side25%
2HVAC both units, plumbing passed30%
3Kitchens/baths, flooring25%
4Finish + punch20%

Total rehab: $48,000 · 11 months calendar (tenant coordination on occupied side)

DSCR refi math

ItemAmount
Appraisal (stabilized)$215,000
DSCR loan (70% LTV)$150,500
Rate8.1% · 30-year
Monthly P&I~$1,108

NOI: Effective gross $2,585 after vacancy → NOI ~$1,770/mo → DSCR ~1.22 at lender file.

Cash out: ~$32,000 extracted toward next door.

Why this BRRRR cleared in a partially occupied building

Two things made this deal harder than a vacant flip — and the structure solved both. First, the 10-day estate window: a Day-2 proof of funds let the sponsor win against two conventional offers stuck in 30-day underwriting. Speed, not price, won the contract. Second, one side stayed occupied at below-market rent during rehab, so the draw schedule was sequenced unit-by-unit (vacant side first) to keep work moving without a tenant dispute.

The exit worked because Indiana is a genuine cash-flow market: at $2,750/mo gross on a $215K stabilized value, NOI cleared a ~1.22 DSCR even at a conservative 70% LTV. The key discipline was modeling Marion County taxes at the post-rehab assessed value, not the estate’s old bill — the single most common reason Indianapolis duplex refis miss coverage.

Takeaway: on occupied value-add, win on speed and sequence draws around the tenant; then let the rent — underwritten with honest taxes — size the cash-out.

Deal timeline — estate close through DSCR refi

PhaseDurationMilestone
LOIDay 0Four offers on estate duplex — sponsor submits with Jaken Finance Group POF
ContractDay 2Seller accepts — proof of funds beats two conventional buyers
AcquisitionDay 10$118,000 close — 85% LTC hard money at 10.5% IO
Rehab Draw 1Weeks 2–4Vacant side demo, panel upgrade, rough electrical
Rehab Draw 2Weeks 5–8HVAC both units, plumbing inspection passed
Rehab Draw 3Weeks 9–14Kitchens/baths, flooring — occupied side coordinated around tenant
Rehab Draw 4Weeks 15–18Finish, punch, exterior
Lease-upMonth 8Below-market tenant renewed at $1,375/mo; vacant side leased at $1,375/mo
StabilizationMonth 11Both units on 12-month leases; $2,750/mo gross documented
DSCR refiMonth 12$150,500 loan at 70% LTV on $215,000 appraisal — ~$32K cash extracted

Total calendar: 12 months from acquisition to refi — 11 months rehab driven by occupied-side sequencing, not scope overrun.

Fountain Square and Marion County market context

Fountain Square sits southeast of downtown Indianapolis in Marion County — a neighborhood in active transition where 2010s-era duplexes trade at $95K–$130K distressed and $200K–$230K stabilized post-renovation. The sponsor’s $118K acquisition sat below the corridor median because one side carried a below-market tenant at $950/mo and the estate wanted certainty over price.

Indianapolis duplex rents in Fountain Square and adjacent Near Eastside blocks ran $1,300–$1,450/side for renovated 2/1 units in 2026 — the sponsor’s $1,375/side stabilization sat at market, not aspirational. Marion County property taxes reassess on sale; the sponsor modeled $385/mo taxes post-rehab vs the seller’s $210/mo pre-renovation bill — the single adjustment that separates Indianapolis BRRRR files that refi from files that miss DSCR coverage.

The Indiana Landlord-Tenant Act allows 30-day notice on month-to-month conversions, but the sponsor negotiated a lease renewal with the existing tenant at $1,375/mo rather than forcing turnover during rehab — avoiding 2–3 months vacancy on half the building that would have dropped gross rent to $2,325/mo and failed the refi.

Fountain Square’s proximity to Fletcher Place, Holy Cross, and the Culture Trail supports long-term appreciation on duplex holds — but this sponsor’s thesis was cash-flow extraction, not land banking. See hard money lenders Indianapolis for Marion County product parameters.

Full economics — bridge through refi

Line itemAmount
Purchase$118,000
Rehab$48,000
All-in cost$166,000
Hard money (85% LTC)$141,100 @ 10.5% IO
Sponsor cash in (gap + carry float)~$24,900
Bridge carry (11 mo avg balance ~$130K @ 10.5%)~$12,550
Appraisal at refi$215,000
DSCR loan (70% LTV)$150,500 @ 8.1%, 30-year
Bridge balance at refi−$118,500
Refi closing costs−$5,200
Net cash extracted~$26,800

The sponsor self-funded portions of rehab between draws to keep the bridge balance at ~$118,500 at refi — below the $141,100 max LTC line. That discipline produced ~$26,800 net cash (rounded to ~$32,000 in the sponsor’s internal accounting including $5,200 in draw reimbursements released at final inspection). Retained equity: $64,500 ($215K − $150.5K).

Monthly cash flow post-refi:

LineMonthly
Gross rent$2,750
Vacancy (6%)−$165
Taxes + insurance−$485
Maintenance / PM (10%)−$275
NOI$1,825
P&I @ 8.1% on $150,500−$1,108
Cash flow~$717/mo

Flip alternative rejected at underwriting

Exit pathProjected result
Retail sale at $225K ARV~$18K net after 8% costs, 12-month hold, IO carry
BRRRR refi (executed)~$32K extracted + $717/mo ongoing cash flow + retained asset

The flip spread compressed because occupied-side rehab extended hold to 11 months — at that timeline, IO carry on $141K consumed $12,550 that a 5-month cosmetic flip would have avoided. The sponsor correctly pivoted to hold exit when Draw 2 revealed $11,200 in HVAC scope on both units — mechanical depth signals BRRRR, not flip velocity.

Operator lessons

Estate sales reward speed, not lowball price. The sponsor matched list price at $118K — the winning variable was Day-2 proof of funds, not a discount. Two conventional offers at $115K and $112K never cleared underwriting in time.

Sequence draws around occupancy. Draw schedule prioritized the vacant side first — occupied side kitchen/bath deferred to Draw 3 so the tenant kept a functional unit through months 1–8. Lenders who require full vacancy on duplex rehab would have disqualified this asset; milestone draws on partial occupancy required before/after photo documentation per unit.

Tax reassessment is not optional in pro forma. Marion County assessed the property at $198K post-rehab for tax purposes — sponsor’s $385/mo tax line at refi matched the bill within $12/mo. Files that model pre-sale tax bills on Indianapolis duplex refis consistently miss 0.08–0.12 DSCR points.

70% LTV discipline. Sponsor requested 75% LTV at refi; underwriting capped at 70% because side-by-side duplex product in Fountain Square carries thinner comp support than suburban Indianapolis duplexes. The 0.05 LTV reduction cost ~$10,750 in proceeds but cleared ratio at 1.22 DSCR without exception pricing.

Pre-Qualify for Indianapolis Hard Money · (833) 264-7776

Frequently asked questions

What rents stabilized this Fountain Square duplex?
$1,375 per side ($2,750/mo gross) on renovated 2/1 units — documented 12-month leases with deposit proof.
What DSCR cleared at refi?
Approximately 1.22 at 70% LTV on $215,000 appraisal — Indiana cash-flow markets support ratio when expenses are not understated.
How fast did hard money close?
10 business days from complete file — speed won against conventional buyer on estate listing.

Fund your next deal with Jaken Finance Group

Hard money, DSCR, and bridge loans for real estate investors nationwide.

Or call (833) 264-7776